Reserve regulation

How the Rules Fit Together

Seven kinds of rule stand behind every statutory reserve. Three bodies write them, four paths make them law, and they bind two different parties. This page shows what sits inside what, follows one policy through all of them, and says who wins when two of them disagree.

The one rule. Only a state's enacted law has legal force. Everything the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) writes gets that force through one of four paths: a legislature enacts it, a commissioner promulgates it, the enacted Standard Valuation Law incorporates it (the Valuation Manual), or state accounting law adopts the manual that carries it (the actuarial guidelines). The Actuarial Standards of Practice (ASOPs) enter through a different door, the actuary's own credential.

The mechanics and timing of each path live on the Regulation Adoption Process page. This page is the map, and the domiciliary state's enacted text always governs.

What sits inside what

Three of the seven kinds of rule are carried inside another one, which is why the same text can be cited from two places. Click any box to open its family card.

STATE LAW The domiciliary state's insurance code what the legislature enacts and the commissioner promulgates Statute: the Standard Valuation Law Statute: the Standard Valuation Law Model #820 as enacted, with local edits Section 11: the Valuation Manual Section 11: the Valuation Manual VM-20 life, VM-21 variable annuities, VM-22 fixed annuities, VM-25 health, VM-G VM-30 opinion, VM-31 report, VM-M tables new edition each January 1, no state vote Regulations the commissioner promulgates Regulations the commissioner promulgates XXX #830, universal life #585, opinion #822, reserve financing #787, health reserves #010 effective dates set state by state Accounting law: the AP&P Manual Accounting law: the AP&P Manual Accounting Practices and Procedures Manual, adopted by state accounting law SSAPs Statements of Statutory Accounting Principles: No. 51R life, 54R health, 61R reinsurance Appendix A: model excerpts A-820 SVL; A-822, A-830, A-010 regulations, reprinted from the model laws and regulations Appendix C: actuarial guidelines Appendix C: actuarial guidelines AG 38, 43, 48 and 51: interpretations of the statute, binding through the manual Prescribed and permitted practices the commissioner can require or allow a departure from either manual; the statement discloses it THE PROFESSION Outside the state's code binds the actuary who signs, not the company ASOPs: Actuarial Standards of Practice ASOPs Actuarial Standards of Practice from the Actuarial Standards Board bind the credentialed actuary Code of Conduct, Precept 3 ASOP 22, 52, 41, 56, 23 VM-30 requires their opinion Practice notes American Academy of Actuaries; describe practice, bind no one
State law: the domiciliary state's insurance code what the legislature enacts and the commissioner promulgates
Accounting law: the AP&P ManualAccounting Practices and Procedures Manual, adopted by state accounting law
SSAPsStatements of Statutory Accounting Principles: No. 51R life, 54R health, 61R reinsurance
Appendix A: model excerptsA-820 SVL; A-822, A-830, A-010 regulations, reprinted from the model laws and regulations
Prescribed and permitted practicesthe commissioner can require or allow a departure from either manual; the statement discloses it
The profession: outside the state's code binds the actuary who signs, not the company
Practice notesAmerican Academy of Actuaries; describe practice, bind no one
Everything the NAIC writes lives inside the domiciliary state's code once the state adopts it; the standards of practice live outside it and bind only the actuary. Nesting shows where a rule lives, not which one wins; for that, see Who wins when they conflict.

One term policy, every rule it touches

A 20-year term policy issued in Minnesota in 2024, followed from the statute to the annual statement. Each stop names the rule that reaches it and what gives that rule force.

The policy: $500,000 of 20-year level term, issued March 15, 2024 by a Minnesota-domiciled life insurer to a Minnesota resident, valued at December 31, 2024. No small-company exemption applies.
  1. State law, from a model law
    Minn. Stat. § 61A.25: the Standard Valuation Law (SVL) as enacted (Model #820 entry, Minn. Stat. § 61A.25)

    Minnesota enacted the NAIC's Standard Valuation Law, Model #820, as Minn. Stat. § 61A.25, including the Section 11 language, so the Valuation Manual carries the force of Minnesota statute for this policy.

    How it binds, and what to verify

    The NAIC drafts in the Life Actuarial (A) Task Force (LATF); its parent committee, then the Executive Committee and Plenary, adopt the text, and nothing binds until a state acts (path one). The accreditation program keeps each state's enacted text close to the model. Still to verify: the year Minnesota enacted the 2009 revision and the subdivision that carries Section 11 verify, and the Minnesota statute that requires the AP&P Manual for the annual statement verify.

  2. Valuation Manual
    VM-20, VM-M, VM-G, VM-31 (Valuation Manual entry, term life regulations)

    Issued after January 1, 2020, the policy is principle-based business: VM-20 sets its reserve as the net premium reserve plus any excess of the deterministic or stochastic reserve over it, with the 2017 Commissioners Standard Ordinary (CSO) table prescribed by VM-M.

    How it binds, and what to verify

    The 2024 edition took effect on January 1, 2024 through Section 11 with no Minnesota vote. VM-G assigns duties to the board, senior management and the qualified actuary; VM-31 documents the work in the principle-based reserving (PBR) actuarial report. Term cannot use the deterministic exclusion test, and most term blocks pass the stochastic exclusion test; the tests and margins are on the Principles-Based Reserves page. Still to verify: Minnesota's PBR operative date verify.

  3. Model regulation, as promulgated
    Regulation XXX (Model #830); Model #787 if ceded (Regulation XXX, Model #787)

    The regulation layer is thin here: VM-20 replaced Regulation XXX for new issues, so XXX governs this company's pre-2020 term instead, and the reserve financing regulation (Model #787) applies only if the block is ceded to a captive.

    How it binds, and what to verify

    A model regulation binds once the commissioner promulgates it (path two). Regulation XXX still reaches older business, and the Valuation Manual's VM-A carries forward the model law and regulation requirements that still apply to Manual business verify. Where a state has not promulgated Model #787, Actuarial Guideline (AG) 48 still carries the captive rule; adoption of #787 has been an accreditation standard since September 1, 2022. Still to verify: Minnesota's Model #787 adoption status verify.

  4. Actuarial guideline
    None sets this reserve (AG 48, Appendix C)

    No guideline sets a 2024 term reserve: AG 48, the interim captive rule, was revised to defer to Model #787 as states adopted it, while AG 38 still governs this company's older universal life with secondary guarantees.

    How it binds, and what to verify

    Guidelines bind through Appendix C of the AP&P Manual (path four); they interpret the statute, they do not revise it. AG 53 reaches the appointed actuary's year-end asset adequacy work where the portfolio holds complex or high-yield assets. Still to verify: AG 53's scope threshold and first effective year-end verify (no instrument page yet).

  5. AP&P Manual and SSAPs
    SSAP No. 51R, Appendix A-820 (Appendix C entry, AP&P publication)

    The reserve is booked under Statement of Statutory Accounting Principles (SSAP) No. 51R, Life Contracts, which points to Appendix A-820, the manual's excerpt of the Standard Valuation Law, so the accounting rule and the valuation rule meet in one number.

    How it binds, and what to verify

    Codification took effect January 1, 2001, and every state requires the manual for the annual statement. SSAP No. 61R applies if the block is reinsured; Appendix A-822 carries the opinion requirement. The AP&P Manual is a paid NAIC publication, so this site quotes none of its text; the Document Library links the publication page and a public state adoption order.

  6. ASOPs
    ASOP No. 52, 22, 41, 56, 23 (ASOPs in the library)

    The qualified actuary who signs the VM-20 work and the appointed actuary who signs the opinion each follow the ASOPs, which bind them personally through the Code of Professional Conduct and never bind the company.

    How it binds, and what to verify

    Precept 3 of the Code requires work that satisfies applicable standards of practice; the Actuarial Board for Counseling and Discipline (ABCD) hears alleged breaches. Under ASOP No. 1 and ASOP No. 41, where the law conflicts with a standard the actuary follows the law and discloses the deviation. The American Academy of Actuaries' life PBR practice note informs the judgment calls and binds no one.

  7. State law reads it
    2024 annual statement, Exhibit 5; VM-30 opinion; VM-31 report (Valuation Manual entry)

    The number lands in the 2024 annual statement, filed by March 1, 2025 with the appointed actuary's VM-30 opinion; the Minnesota Department of Commerce reads it, examines it, and can prescribe or permit departures, which the notes disclose.

    How it binds, and what to verify

    This is where “state law wins” becomes visible. A Minnesota rule that differs from the AP&P Manual is a prescribed practice; a written commissioner approval for one company is a permitted practice; SSAP No. 1 requires either to be disclosed in Note 1 with its effect on surplus (see Who wins when they conflict). Still to verify: the VM-31 report's April 1 due date verify.

Same seven kinds, three policies

Which layer carries the method, by product and issue year
Kind of ruleTerm life, issued 2024Universal life with secondary guarantees (ULSG), issued 2010Long-term care (LTC), issued 2020
StatuteSVL as enacted; Section 11 carries the manualSVL as enacted; Section 11 not yet operativeSVL as enacted; Section 11 carries VM-25
State regulationNot in play for the method; XXX governs the company's pre-2020 termRegulation XXX #830 and the universal life (UL) model #585, as promulgatedHealth reserves Model #010, as promulgated
Valuation ManualVM-20, VM-M (2017 CSO), VM-31, VM-30Not in play for the reserve; VM-30 governs today's opinionVM-25 points to Appendix A-010 verify; VM-30 opinion
Actuarial guidelineNone sets the reserveAG 38 sets the reserve, through Appendix CAG 51 asset adequacy testing, through Appendix C
AP&P Manual and SSAPsSSAP No. 51R; Appendix A-820SSAP No. 51R; Appendix A-830SSAP No. 54R; Appendix A-010
ASOPsNo. 52, 22, 41No. 22, 40, 41No. 18, 22, 41

For long-term care the same model, #010, appears in three layers; for 2010 universal life a guideline sets the reserve; for 2024 term the Valuation Manual does. The product and the issue year decide which layer carries the method.

Seven kinds of rule

Each stop above is one of seven kinds of rule. Five are written by the NAIC and reach the company through the four paths into the state's law; the ASOPs reach the actuary through the credential. The table is the figure in rows.

THE INSTRUMENT THE PATH INTO STATE LAW WHAT IT BINDS WRITTEN BY THE NAIC Model law Model law SVL, Model #820 Model regulation Model regulation XXX #830, UL #585, opinion #822 Valuation Manual Valuation Manual VM-20, VM-21, VM-22, VM-30 Actuarial guideline Actuarial guideline AG 38, 43, 48, 51 AP&P Manual and SSAPs AP&P Manual and SSAPs SSAP 51R, 54R; Appendix A, C WRITTEN BY THE ACTUARIAL STANDARDS BOARD ASOPs ASOPs ASOP 22, 52, 41 The domiciliary state insurance code and accounting law Path 1: enacted as statute Path 2: promulgated as regulation Path 3: SVL Section 11incorporates each edition Path 4: accounting law adoptsthe AP&P Manual, Appendix C inside The actuary's credential Code of Conduct, Precept 3 The company's reserve Exhibit 5 of the annual statement, set by the state's enacted law The actuary who signs opinion (VM-30), report (VM-31)
Path 1: the legislature enacts it as statute Binds: the company
Path 2: the commissioner promulgates it as regulation Binds: the company
Path 3: the enacted SVL incorporates it, Section 11 Binds: the company
Path 4: state accounting law adopts the AP&P Manual Binds: the company
The credential: Code of Professional Conduct, Precept 3 Binds: the actuary, and the state requires that actuary's opinion (VM-30)
Nothing the NAIC adopts binds on its own; follow each instrument to the path it enters by, then to the party it binds. Click an instrument to open its card.
Who writes each kind of rule, how it becomes binding, and whom it binds
Kind of ruleWritten byBecomes binding throughBindsChangesOn the trace
State lawstatute and regulationthe legislature and the commissionernone needed; it is the doorthe companyon the state's own schedulestops 1 and 7
Model lawNAIC, Life Actuarial (A) Task Force (LATF)enacted by the legislature as statutethe companyyears, state by statestop 1
Model regulationNAIC (LATF; Health Actuarial (B) Task Force)promulgated by the commissioner under the statutethe companymonths to years; state effective datesstop 3
Valuation ManualNAIC, by three-fourths voteSVL Section 11, each edition January 1the companyevery January 1stop 2
Actuarial guidelineAGNAIC (LATF)Appendix C of the AP&P Manualthe companyimmediate on its stated datestop 4
AP&P Manual and SSAPsAccounting Practices and Procedures Manual; Statements of Statutory Accounting PrinciplesNAIC Statutory Accounting Principles (E) Working Groupstate accounting law and accreditationthe companyannual editionstop 5
ASOPsActuarial Standards of PracticeActuarial Standards Board (ASB)Code of Professional Conduct, Precept 3the actuary, not the companyASB adoption, stated effective datestop 6

The six families

One card per instrument family, in the same order as the figures and the table: what it is in one sentence, the instruments on this site, and a fold with where to read it and its conflict rule. Prescribed mortality tables are not a family; they ride whichever instrument carries them (Adoption Process, section 8).

NAIC, enacted by legislaturesModel law

A draft statute written for legislatures. It binds once a state enacts it, usually with local edits. The Standard Valuation Law is the one every reserve stands on.

Where to read it, and in a conflict
Read it
The NAIC model laws in the Document Library, then your state's enacted version (Minnesota: Minn. Stat. § 61A.25).
Examples
  • SVL #820: Section 3 requires the opinion, Section 11 incorporates the Valuation Manual.
  • Nonforfeiture #808: the cash value floor, sharing tables with the reserve standard through VM-02.
  • 2001 CSO #814: the table a whole generation of formula reserves still uses.
In a conflict: the state's enacted text wins over the NAIC model, since the model has no force of its own.

NAIC, promulgated by commissionersModel regulation

A draft rule written for commissioners. It binds once a state's commissioner promulgates it under authority the statute grants, on that state's own effective date.

Where to read it, and in a conflict
Read it
The NAIC model regulations in the Document Library, then the state register or administrative code where your commissioner promulgated it.
Examples
  • XXX #830: still governs every term and secondary guarantee policy issued before the company moved to VM-20.
  • The Actuarial Opinion and Memorandum Regulation (AOMR) #822: the source text VM-30 was built from.
  • #787: AG 48 made permanent, and an accreditation standard since September 1, 2022.
In a conflict: the enabling statute wins over the regulation, and for a policy inside the Valuation Manual's scope the Manual carries the method.

NAIC, incorporated by the SVLValuation Manual

The operative reserve requirements since 2017. It binds through Section 11 of the enacted Standard Valuation Law; where a state enacted that text, each annual edition takes effect without a state vote.

Where to read it, and in a conflict
Read it
The NAIC Valuation Manual page carries the current edition free of charge.
Examples
  • VM-20: net premium, deterministic and stochastic reserves for life policies issued since 2020.
  • VM-21: absorbed the AG 43 method for variable annuities and now covers every in-force contract.
  • VM-22: principle-based reserves for non-variable annuities from 2026, with a three-year transition.
In a conflict: the statute wins; where the Manual is silent, or in the commissioner's view not in compliance with the law, the commissioner prescribes by regulation.

NAIC, carried in Appendix CActuarial guideline

The NAIC's interpretation of existing valuation law. Published in Appendix C of the AP&P Manual, it binds statutory reporting in every state on its stated effective date.

Where to read it, and in a conflict
Read it
The NAIC actuarial guidelines page; the authoritative copy is Appendix C of the AP&P Manual.
Examples
  • AG 48: the fast path first, then revised to defer to Model #787.
  • AG 43: revised so variable annuity reserves follow VM-21.
  • AG 51: stand-alone long-term care asset adequacy testing since year-end 2017.
In a conflict: the statute or regulation wins, since a guideline interprets and does not revise; departing from one still needs a prescribed or permitted practice.

NAIC, adopted by accounting lawAP&P Manual and SSAPs

The statutory accounting codebook, codified in 2001: the SSAPs, model-law excerpts in Appendix A, and the guidelines in Appendix C. States require it for the annual statement.

Where to read it, and in a conflict
Read it
The manual is a paid NAIC publication, so this site quotes none of it; a state adoption order such as Virginia's on the Adoption Process page is the public text.
Examples
  • SSAP No. 51R sends life reserves to Appendix A-820 and the opinion to A-822.
  • Appendix B holds interpretations; Appendix C holds the guidelines.
In a conflict: the state wins; it can prescribe or permit a departure from the manual, and SSAP No. 1 requires the departure to be disclosed with its effect on surplus.

Actuarial Standards BoardASOPs

Standards from the Actuarial Standards Board. They bind the credentialed actuary through the Code of Professional Conduct, not the company. Academy practice notes describe practice and bind no one.

Where to read it, and in a conflict
Read it
The Actuarial Standards Board publishes every standard free of charge; the Academy publishes the Code and the practice notes.
Examples
  • ASOP No. 22: the standard behind the VM-30 opinion.
  • ASOP No. 52: assumption setting, margins and the VM-31 report under VM-20.
  • Academy practice notes: informational by their own disclaimer.
In a conflict: the law wins for the actuary, who complies and discloses the deviation; Precept 3 is enforced by the Actuarial Board for Counseling and Discipline (ABCD), never against the company.

Who wins when they conflict

Two chains of authority. The company follows the state's ladder from the top; the actuary follows the Code of Professional Conduct and discloses when the law pulls the other way. This is an actuary's reading, not legal advice.

Binds the company

  1. The domiciliary state's statute, including the Valuation Manual it incorporates through Section 11Highest. Where the manual is silent, or in the commissioner's view not in compliance with the law, Section 11 lets the commissioner prescribe by regulation.
  2. The domiciliary state's regulations and commissioner action: model regulations as promulgated, prescribed and permitted practices, examination ordersSits under the statute. Can depart from the AP&P Manual; the departure is disclosed in the statement with its surplus effect.
  3. The NAIC manuals as adopted by reference: the AP&P Manual (SSAPs, Appendix A, Appendix C) and the annual statement instructionsBinding everywhere at once. Inside the manual, the Preamble ranks the SSAPs above interpretations and the statement instructions.
  4. Guidance without force: Academy practice notes, Society of Actuaries (SOA) research, NAIC staff responses, this siteUseful for method, never a defense in an examination.

Binds the actuary

  1. The Code of Professional Conduct, Precept 3, and the ASOPsBind the person who signs. The company's reserve is unaffected by a standard the company never adopted.
  2. When the law conflictsThe actuary follows the law and discloses the deviation in the communication (ASOP No. 1; ASOP No. 41).

The pairings that come up

Eight conflicts and the source that settles each
ConflictWho winsWhy, and the source
The NAIC model text and the state's enacted versionThe state's textModels have no force until enacted, usually with local edits (Adoption Process, path one).
The Valuation Manual and the enacted SVLThe statuteSection 11: where the manual is silent or not in compliance with the law, the commissioner prescribes by regulation (Model #820).
The Valuation Manual and a model regulation such as XXXWhichever covers the issue yearVM-20 for principle-based business, the regulation for earlier issues; VM-A lists what carries forward (Regulation Timeline).
An actuarial guideline and a statute or regulationThe statute or regulationGuidelines interpret, they do not revise; departing still needs a prescribed or permitted practice (NAIC actuarial guidelines).
The AP&P Manual and the state's accounting rulesThe statePrescribed and permitted practices, disclosed in the notes with the surplus effect (AP&P Manual Preamble; SSAP No. 1).
An ASOP and the law, for the actuaryThe lawComply and disclose the deviation (ASOP No. 1; ASOP No. 41); the company was never bound by the standard.
An ASOP and an Academy practice noteThe ASOPPractice notes are not standards, by their own disclaimer (American Academy of Actuaries).
The domicile and another licensed stateThe domicile, for the statutory statementOther states rely on it through accreditation; New York imposes its own rules, such as Regulation 147 (Adoption Process, state variation).
Why the state always wins

The McCarran-Ferguson Act of 1945 leaves insurance regulation to the states, and there is no federal reserve standard. The Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) and the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA) reach registered products, not reserves. Tax reserves under Internal Revenue Code Section 807 are a separate calculation that references the statutory method. Generally accepted accounting principles (GAAP) and International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS) are different books under different authority. The federal role is on the Adoption Process page.

Scope: this site is model-level. State-by-state adoption is not tracked here, so check the enacted text before quoting a rule as your state's law; the Document Library shows what a complete state version looks like.

Terms on this page

Every acronym is expanded where it first appears; this fold collects them for a reader who lands mid-page.

Terms on this page
NAIC
National Association of Insurance Commissioners, the state regulators' standard-setting body; it writes models and the Valuation Manual but binds no one directly.
LATF
Life Actuarial (A) Task Force, the NAIC group that drafts life and annuity reserve models, the Valuation Manual and actuarial guidelines.
SAPWG
Statutory Accounting Principles (E) Working Group, the NAIC group that drafts the SSAPs and interpretations in the AP&P Manual.
SVL
Standard Valuation Law, NAIC Model #820, the statute every state enacts to require minimum reserves; its 2009 revision added Section 11.
Section 11
The SVL section that incorporates the Valuation Manual and makes each NAIC-adopted edition effective in the state without further state action.
Valuation Manual
The NAIC document, adopted 2012 and operative since 2017, holding VM-20, VM-21, VM-22, VM-25, VM-30, VM-31, VM-M and VM-G among others.
CSO table
Commissioners Standard Ordinary mortality table (1941, 1958, 1980, 2001, 2017), the prescribed mortality for formula reserves; VM-M carries the 2017 CSO.
AG
Actuarial guideline, an NAIC interpretation of existing law for a specific product or practice, published in Appendix C of the AP&P Manual.
AP&P Manual
Accounting Practices and Procedures Manual, the NAIC's codified statutory accounting, a paid publication every state adopts for the annual statement.
SSAP
Statement of Statutory Accounting Principles, a numbered standard in the AP&P Manual; SSAP No. 51R sends life reserves to Appendix A-820.
Appendix A, B and C
AP&P Manual appendices: A reproduces model law and regulation excerpts, B holds interpretations, C reproduces the actuarial guidelines.
Codification
The NAIC project, effective January 1, 2001, that replaced the earlier manuals with one AP&P Manual every state adopts.
Accreditation
The NAIC program under which states review one another's solvency laws against required standards, including the SVL and the AP&P Manual.
Prescribed and permitted practices
A state rule that departs from the AP&P Manual (prescribed), or a written commissioner approval for one company (permitted); both are disclosed under SSAP No. 1.
Domiciliary state
The state that chartered the insurer; its enacted law governs the statutory statement every other state receives.
ASB
Actuarial Standards Board, established by the American Academy of Actuaries in 1988, which adopts the ASOPs by its own vote.
ASOP
Actuarial Standard of Practice, a professional standard binding the credentialed actuary through the Code of Professional Conduct, not the company.
Code of Professional Conduct
The code adopted by the United States actuarial organizations; Precept 3 requires work that satisfies applicable standards of practice.
ABCD
Actuarial Board for Counseling and Discipline, which hears alleged breaches of the Code and can recommend discipline by the actuary's organization.
Academy practice notes
Documents from the American Academy of Actuaries that describe current practice; they bind no one.
Appointed actuary and qualified actuary
The appointed actuary signs the VM-30 opinion; the qualified actuary is responsible for the principle-based reserve work and the VM-31 report.
Exhibit 5
Aggregate Reserve for Life Contracts, the life annual statement exhibit where the policy reserve is reported.

A chip marked verify flags a statement taken from a secondary source that has not yet been checked against the primary document. The page cites public sources only: the NAIC, state legislature and revisor sites, the Society of Actuaries, the American Academy of Actuaries and the Actuarial Standards Board.

Related

Regulation Adoption Process

Each path in detail: who votes, the thresholds, accreditation, and state timing.

Regulation Timeline

Every instrument by the years it governed new business.

Document Library

The manual, the models, the guidelines, the ASOPs, and enacted state text.

Principles-Based Reserves

How a VM-20 reserve is built, and VM-20, VM-21 and VM-22 compared.

Term life: regulations and timeline

The traced policy's regimes and assumptions in depth.